The political class are unanimously convinced that we must continue to finance their exciting adventure in Afghanistan . We are always told the reasons for this are ,'not explained well enough', they feel badly about it , they often say so ... Au contraire say I , from the Pakistan domino theory, to bewilderingly inconsequential statistics about Afghani female education, they do a magnificent and incessant job . Its almost as if someone had something to hide , there is so much explaining .
The most confusing reason for rushing around a desert shooting people, is that otherwise we will be blown up by Muslims ( they say). This might explain occupying Yorkshire or Islington,given the provenance of our home brewed bombers , or , not letting so many in in the first place. …but Afghanistan .? I just worry that people will suspect that Politicians just prefer strutting around on the world stage at our expense to getting our rubbish collected. Lucky we know exactly how high minded they are isn`t it .
Those thinking of supporting nice Mr. Cameron have been accused of being autistic and castrated by the French Europe Minster . Apparently our wish for self determination will inconvenience the tribes of scribblers we employ , which is terribly inconsiderate , A little crestfallen the Nation kicks a can thoughtfully along the gutter and starts coming to terms with its irrelevance… after all even the US only cares about us if we do as we are told by the Germans ( they say). Still castrated though we may be, we keep buggering on and considering our lowly status we are lucky we were allowed to join in the fightiong at all .Naturally other more important countries have done far more ..
Troops in Afghanistan -United States - 68,000 ,UK 9500 ,Germany 3380 ,France 3070 ,Italy - 2,795 ,Netherlands 2600 ,Poland 2030 ,Spain - 1,000 etc. Oh dear , that’s strange and spending is also perlexing . US equipment spend in Afghanistan for 2009 is £463,000 for each soldier. For Britain's 9,000 troops in Helmand the Afghan-specific equipment spend equates to just £288,889 per head. For Canadian troops fighting in Kandahar province, the spend is equivalent to £507,539 per soldier .Now lets ets have a look at the butchers bill..Dead Soldiers- Britain 230 ,Denmark with 28 ( worst kill ratio) ,Holland 41 ,France 36 ,Germany 36 Italy 22 ,Poland 14 Etc. ...I suppose its just a good job we are not an important country with international obligations we take seriously like our European betters . Best to let them get on with it I think . Thats enough , bring the troops home
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
If I knew how I would do those witty categories but I don`t so these are just links
- A Very British Dude
- Aaron a G String
- Access Interviews
- Adam Smith
- Adrian Yalland
- Alpha ville
- Anyone But Ken
- Archbishop Cranmer
- Arthurian Legend
- Asquith
- Back Boris
- BBC
- Behind Blue Eyes
- Bel is Thinking
- Ben Brogan
- Biassed BBC
- Blu BLog
- Blue Contrarian
- BLue Eyes
- Bob ( The Commie ) Piper
- Boris Johnson's Blog
- Boulton and Co.
- Brights Blog
- Cassillis
- Centre For Policy Studies
- Centre For Social Justice
- Charlotte Gore
- Chloe Smith
- Chris Paul
- Chris Whiteside
- Chritopher Hitchens
- Cicero Songs
- CityUnslicker
- Civitas
- Coffe House
- Comment is Free
- Communist Party
- Compass
- Conservative Home
- Conservative Party
- Conservative Party Reptile
- Croydonian
- Daily Mail
- Daily Referendum
- daisy
- devils kitchen
- Diablo
- Dictionary
- Dizzy Thinks
- Don Paskini
- Donal Blaney
- Donna Edmunds
- Doughty Street
- Duncan
- Economist
- Economists Forum
- Ed Clark
- Elektro Kevin
- Ellee Seymour
- English Nationalist Party
- ESRC
- EU Referendum
- Eugenides
- Evan Price
- Evening Standard Blog
- Fink
- Fortean Times
- Frank Field
- Funny Liberal Snob .( Hug a Hoodie)
- Gaby Hinslif
- Gareth Young
- Global Warming Foundation
- Guardian
- Guardian
- Guido Fawkes
- Hadley Road
- Half Blood Welshman
- Harry`s Place
- Hatfield Girl
- High Beam Research
- Hopi Sen
- Iain Dale's Diary
- Idle
- IEA
- IEA Blog
- Independent
- Inter generational Foundation
- Ipsos Mori
- Islington Conservatives Blogspot
- Istanbul Tory
- James Cleverly
- John B
- John Redwood
- John Trenchard
- Justin Hinchcliffe
- Labour Home
- Labour List
- Left eye Luke
- Letter From A Tory
- Lewes Coucil
- Lewes Forum
- Liam Murray
- Lib Dem Voice
- Lib Dum Dumbos witter on
- Liberal Conspiracy
- Libertarian Alliance
- Lilith
- Limbaugh
- Lst Of The Few( Theo Spark)
- Ludwig
- Mark Wadsworth
- Mega Blog
- Melanie Phillips
- Mens Sana
- Mermaid of Moorgate
- Migration Watch
- Milliband
- Ministry of truth
- Miss C Hunt ..( A Floozy )
- Monck
- Mountjoy
- Mrs. Small Print
- Ms Smack (NSFW)
- Mutley
- Nadine Dorries
- New Statesman
- news Now
- Next Left
- Nick Coen Speccie Blog
- Nick Cohen
- Nick Robinson
- Norfolk Blogger
- Norman Baker Watch
- Norman Tebbit
- Norman Tebbit
- Nose Monkey
- Nourishing Obscurity
- Oliver Kamm
- Oliver Kamm
- Open Europe
- Open Europe
- Open Left
- Page With A View
- Paul Waugh
- Peter Hitchens
- Pickled lefty
- Poetry On Line
- Policy Exchange
- Political Betting
- Political Futures
- Politics Home
- Poltical Umpire
- Prague Tory
- Progress
- Prospect
- Quaequam
- Rachel Johnson
- Raedwald
- Raincoaster
- Red Tory
- Reform
- right student
- Robert Peston
- Roger Thornhill Real Time
- Sam Coates
- Sammy`s data
- Scroblene ....
- Site meter
- SKY NEWS
- Sky News
- Slugger O`Toole
- Social Cohesion
- Standpoint
- Stuart Sharpe
- Sussex Express
- Suz Blog
- Swingometer
- Taking Liberties
- Tax Payers Alliance
- Telegraph
- The Brute
- The Drudge Report
- The Editors
- The Freedom Association
- The Gore
- The Onion
- The Politics Show
- The Quizzical Gaze
- The religion of peace
- The Wrong Man
- Theos
- Tim Worstall
- Times On Line
- Toby Young
- Tom Harris
- Tom Harris
- Tony Sharp
- Tory Bear
- Total Politics
- TPA Blog
- UK Bubble
- UK Libertarian Party
- UK Polling Report
- Used To Be Lefty Woman
- Weasel Words
- Welshcakes Lemon
- Westminster
- Westmonster
- Wife in the North
14 comments:
Look, if you're trying to get rid of me commenting here just say, you don't have to keep disappearing.
Glad to see you posting, Newms, as ever xx
Ha .. more like trying to get rid of me
Yes, that's enough, bring the troops home. I see Boz is arguing to keep them there. Poor chap's had a talking to, maybe?
Apparently our wish for self determination will inconvenience the tribes of scribblers we employ , which is terribly inconsiderate , A little crestfallen the Nation kicks a can thoughtfully along the gutter and starts coming to terms with its irrelevance… after all even the US only cares about us if we do as we are told by the Germans
Oh how I've missed you.
Time to call them back.
It may have worked in 2001 but its a bit late now. The USA was in vietnam from 1965{in strength} to 1970 {in strength}
The whole place went down the toilet in 1975. Death, mayhem and communism followed.
Today they invest in beach resorts for western tourists.
I'm here too.
Five minutes and the nutters are back !
You missed the meeting on Friday. (Philipa, Idle, Blue Eyes ... and ME !) That Mayfair Tapas venue will never be the same !!!
http://electro-kevin-electro-kevin.blogspot.com/2009/11/for-ib.html
You really need to listen to a mother tearing Brown a new arsehole. She agrees we should be in Afghanistan. Whatever.
If we're going to be there we should be there far better resourced ...
and that for me says all we need to know about Brown's lack of committment for this mission.
And let's not forget:
Two Christian fundamentalists knelt side-by-side, shoulder-to-shoulder and prayed to God after the events of 9/11
They heard voices in their heads and obeyed them.
They then embarked on a Holy War. A Crusade. This is the mammoth in the spare bedroom.
The rest is a matter of bewildered politicians trying to justify something they don't truly believe in themselves.
Had the 'war on terror' not been such a monumental fuck up we would have been in Iran by now too. Continuing the Crusade.
Bring the troops home.
And exectute Tony Blair whose self-aggrandising conduct in America is an utter betrayal of our country and our armed forces.
Bill I am not sure what your point is there , why is it too late ? What are we going to achieve and why is it our problem . generally I am all in favour of supporting the US but we seem to get no thanks
EK saw that and nice to hear you are alove and kicking
N: point is in the time we have been in Afghanistan the USA and Korea had committed a million troops and a huge sum of treasure to making the Vietnamese like democracy.
The South Vietnamese were too corrupt to get it together, even after years of training and US military equipment given to them and the idealogical North steamrollered the place once the USA pulled its troops out.
The point is if the country you are trying to protect is corrupt to too high a degree then it can't be saved except by a} basing troops their permanently
b} Keeping troops in place until the ally goes through a period of change
c} bribe the opponents not to attack.
I think its probably too late in Afghanistan now. After nearly a decade the UN is pretty much where it was in 2002. Only now its minus the goodwill of the citizens who just want everyone to go away.
The thing is BQ it mnay be very bad of me but I do not see the fate of Afganistan in some exitential way as my problem .
"I do not see the fate of Afganistan in some exitential way as my problem"
I have to agree and beg your indulgence to remind all that Persia was a civilised society long before the Roman empire made it's bid to rule (which they never succeeded at). If the Romans failed and the Russians failed then I can't honestly see what our little island is hoping to gain there??
Bill Quango, you omit to mention that Islamism was not & is not a force to be reckoned with in Vietnam. While there are some wonderful people in Afghanistan, as long as the likes of not only the Taliban but also supposedly respectable conservatives like Karzai & those a bit more "moderate" than him persist, the country will not improve.
A country like Iran has a somewhat better chance as it is more materially developed first, & might in time be able to become secular. But the odds for Afghanistan are less hopeful.
Maybe only a few Afghans support theocracy & most oppose it. But too often the silent majority is permanently silent & a few can stamp on the majority. (Which is why we have the rule of law in the first place).
It does seem i'm supporting a troop commitment, but I'm not trying to. Bring them all home and let the country sort itself out.
We should have left once we failed to find Osama.
Massive troop commitment IS the solution though.
The study at the end of the Vietnam war found that they needed to have a massive force to invade the territory of north Vietnam and Laos and Cambodia and destroy the insurgencies bases and support. There is little point in fighting the guerilla forces themselves. its the supply of arms, food, recruits, weapons and planning, money and communication centres that need to be destroyed. This seems to be what Pakistan is , finally, doing. This should have been day one strategy.. but , of course, there was no strategy. the troops went in to kill Osama. Then, to defeat the Taliban. Then to keep us safe from terrorists. Now, to build a democracy. Tomorrow to secure the region from the Chinese.. who knows what the excuse will be.?
"I don't know what happened. When I left we were winning." Old Vietnam veterans bumper sticker.
Well I could accept that others are better qualified than me to judge our long term security interests if it were not so obvious that we are doing all the sharp end work without the resources and for no thanks
Post a Comment