Thursday, August 02, 2007

Its the Little Differences

Like being able to drink a beer in a cinema in Holland ...Speaking of the Dutch they , of course rejected the Constitution said to be identical to the Treaty soi disant on which we do not get a vote . How little are the differences here?
Hans -Gert Poettering MEP President of the EU has said that statistics about the extent to which the treaty was a cut and paste job are highly misleading.(96% say Open Europe .)Compared to the draft Constitution , he says , the treaty contains opts outs on the Charter of fundamental rights as well as a wider exemption in Justice and Home Affairs which mean that although the text is almost identical most of it will not apply to us . Not so very difficult to understand if its true . In fact the anecdotal evidence that the treaty and the Constitution are the same is largely drawn from the reaction of other foreign leaders announcing it as celebration but they are , supposedly in a fundamentally different position to us so the President’s remarks are well aimed
.We have as many genes in common with a frog but the effect is contrasting . .


So how strong are the opt outs . How red are the red lines ? We cannot trust Hans Gert Pottering and I suspect Conservatives are right to scent blood. As yet , however, the case is not proved.

4 comments:

Ed said...

I am no expert, but I would think that an ECJ decision a few years down the line will be enough to delete these "opt-outs". The fact is we are not suited to this kind of Napoleonic legal setup with "rights" instead of "freedoms" etc.

I just don't understand why our politicos sign us up to this guff - there must be a better way.

By the way you can drink beer in some cinemas in England now - for me that is the kind of European Integration that is worthwhile!

Newmania said...

Really , it was the line in Pulp fiction I was thinking of Ed and I am certain you are right in what you say otherwise

Ed said...

it was the line in Pulp fiction I was thinking of

Thought so. Still can't get a beer in McDonald's in England.

Newmania said...

Le Big Mac

Blog Archive